Chocolate Chip Crunch Mystery Cookies

If you follow along with the “Hannah Swenson Mystery” series on Hallmark Mysteries, then you have to be familiar with Hannah’s famous chocolate chip crunch cookie! I made this cookie extra rich with browned butter, huge chocolate chunks and a sweet mystery inside!

Ingredients:

-2 1/4 cup flour

-1 teaspoon baking soda

-1/2 teaspoon salt

-2 sticks unsalted butter

-2 1/2 teaspoons plain Greek yogurt

-2 eggs

-1 1/2 cups packed brown sugar

-1 1/2 tablespoons vanilla extract

-2 semi-sweet chocolate baking bars

-Small can cherry pie filling

Directions:

First melt your butter in a skillet, stirring continuously until melted and starting to become golden in color. In order for it not to burn, pour it into a heat safe bowl and set aside to cool for 10 minutes.

In a small bowl, combine flour, baking soda and salt. Set aside.

In a large mixing bowl, using an electric mixer, combine melted butter and brown sugar. Slowly mix in eggs, vanilla and yogurt.

Chop up chocolate bar into chunks and add into the dough mixture, leaving some behind to place on top of each cookie.

Chill dough for 30 minutes and preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Scoop chilled dough into your hand and flatten a bit to make a well in the center. Place a small dollop of cherry pie filling in the center and cover top with more cookie dough. Place on cookie sheet and add more chocolate chunks to the top. Bake for 20 minutes.

Similar Posts

  • Peach Cobbler Mystery Cookies

    Counting down to the newest “Hannah Swenson” movie premiering on Hallmark Mysteries, I’m making different baked goods inspired by the previous Hannah Swenson movies! This recipe is inspired by a “Murder She Baked” movie, before the series changed its name to the “Hannah Swenson Mysteries”.  Since Hannah’s character usually makes cookies, I’m turning peach cobbler…

  • Sand Castle Cake

    “A Castle of Our Own” on Hallmark Channel was a sweet, coastal themed movie, all about new beginnings. The sand castle contest was merely a metaphor, as the parts that had fall apart can always be re-built. In the spirit of new beginnings, and of course, summer, I made a castle cake! Ingredients: -White cake…

  • Lemon Drop Pie

    “The Magic of Lemon Drops” on Hallmark Channel was in fact such a magical movie to watch! The delicious ‘lemon drop pie’ was a key component in this movie. Especially the lemon drops, which possessed the power to allow you to live one day in an alternate reality and given the choice to choose which…

  • Stiletto Cupcakes

    “Head Over Heels” on Hallmark Channel inspired these beauties! So many fabulous shoes in this movie, but only one shoe was Addi’s (played by Rebecca Dalton) Inspo to design shoes, and it was the OG ‘Delaney Diaz’ red pump! These cupcakes are so fun to make and great for a birthday party or bachelorette party/bridal…

  • Sicilian Seafood Salad

    This seafood salad is a classic dish in Sicily, where Hallmark Channel movie “Missing The Boat” takes place! It’s fresh and bright, perfect for a sail around the coast of Sicily! I loved everything about this movie! From the scenery, to the storyline, and of course the two main characters played by Emilie Ullerup and…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *